Dozen Artisan Plain Bagels
Hand-rolled on Shelter Island with all-natural, premium ingredients. Chewy, golden, and perfectly balanced.
No toppings, no distractions, just classic bagel goodness that's your blank canvas for cream cheese, lox, or a breakfast sandwich. Nitrogen-flushed and sealed for peak freshness.
How fresh bagels ship
Our bagels are baked without preservatives, so we only ship them 2-day or overnight. You choose your shipping speed at checkout, with rates based on weight and destination. We do not offer slower shipping because we want your bagels arriving as fresh as possible.
We bake and ship Monday through Wednesday, with a noon Eastern cutoff. Orders placed before noon on a shipping day go out that same day. Orders placed Thursday through Sunday ship the following Monday.
When your bagels arrive, toast or warm them before eating for the best texture and flavor. Freeze any you are not planning to enjoy right away.
Read our Shipping & Freshness guide →
Why people love them:
- 12 hand-rolled Plain Bagels
- Made with all-natural, premium ingredients
- Nitrogen-sealed to lock in freshness
What people are saying
Real reviews from real customers.
“We ordered 3 boxes of bagel chips for our wedding welcome bags and they were incredible!”
Google Review
“The best bagel chips I've ever had in my life.”
“Absolutely the best bagel I have ever had.”
Etsy Review
“Tasted amazing. I finished almost two bags the same day they arrived.”
Etsy Review
“Delicious, spicy, savory — makes me look forward to breakfast.”
Etsy Review
“Love this company!! Delish!”
Faire