It started with a bagel obsession, one hungry island and a wildly unexpected idea.

During COVID, Darryn decided to leave luxury travel behind and learn how to make bagels, despite having zero kitchen experience. Amy, his wife, laughed when he first told her. Then she realized he was completely serious.

Together, they opened Shelter Island's first bagel shop in 2022 and created something far from ordinary: handmade bagels, overstuffed sandwiches, unexpected flavors and a space packed with personality.

Every bagel is made from scratch and baked fresh. Every sandwich is built to satisfy. Every detail is designed to make you smile.