Shop Reviews Menu About Contact FAQ Wholesale

Your cart is empty

Continue Shopping

Your Cart (0)

Continue Shopping

Reviews

Customers are saying

4.55 ★ (11)

Verified

Open All Year Hours change with the season. Check Instagram for current hours

Visit Us

25 W Neck Rd
Shelter Island, NY 631-749-5363 hello@eccentricbagel.com Contact

Keep It Eccentric

Explore

Shop Menu About Wholesale Artisan Bagels & Island Life

Join The Eccentric Club

New flavors, seasonal hours, and what's coming out of the oven.

Privacy Policy Refund Policy Shipping Policy © 2026 The Eccentric Bagel